Duke’s early exits from the NCAA tournament over the last four years has been a huge topic of conversation today. It’s been postulated that Duke was fatigued, that their recruiting left them short, their offensive system is flawed, and that K was tired. Let’s look at a few points of discussion.
Recent Results
2008 Second Round
2007 First Round
2006 Sweet 16
2005 Sweet 16
2004 Final Four
2003 Sweet 16
2002 Sweet 16
2001 National Champions
Recruiting
Here are the members of Duke’s recent classes:
2007 – Overall #8
*Kyle Singler – #5 overall, #1 PF
*Taylor King: – #37 overall, #12 PF
*Nolan Smith: – #39 overall, #8 SG
2006 – Overall #5
*Gerald Henderson – #11 overall, #2 SG
Brian Zoubek – #24 overall, #3 C
Lance Thomas – #42 overall, #13 SF
*Jon Scheyer – #71 overall, #15 SG
2005 – Overall #2
*Josh McRoberts – #1 PF – Went pro
*Greg Paulus – #1 PG
*Eric Boateng – #3 C
Martynas Pocius – #16 SG
Jamal Boykin – #20 PF – trans to Cal
2004 – Overall #6
*Shaun Livingston – #1 PG – direct NBA
*DeMarcus Nelson – #5 SG
David McCLure – #13 SF
2003 – Overall #18
*Luol Deng – #1 SF – 1 year, then NBA
2002 – Overall #1
*Sean Dockery – overall #20, #6 PG
*Shavlik Randolph – overall #30, #6 PF 3 yrs, then NBA
*JJ Redick – overall #32, #2 SG
Shelden Williams – overall #49, #3 PF
*Mike Thompson – #53 overall, #5 C – Trans to N’Western
Lee Melchionni – NR
* McDonald’s All-American
Duke’s Donut Offense
Obviously there is no shortage of overall talent in the recruiting history. Some charge Duke with no inside presence. Freshman Kyle Singler averaged 13.3 pts points per game. His season became more consistent and more productive until about Valentine’s Day. After that, Singler’s shooting percentages went down and his activity at the free throw line became more erratic. In the final 6 games, Singler attempted a total of 6 free throws.
Unfortunately for Duke there was no big man to back up Singler. K ran off McRoberts and Boeteng. Sophomore Lance Thomas is 6-8, but isn’t an inside force. He played 18.5 minutes per game and averaged 4.3 points per game and 3.3 rebounds. Against the talented big men of UNC, Thomas only played 12 minutes! It’s unclear just what Krzyzewski wants Thomas to be. A post up player is certainly not in the cards, though he took no 3’s this season. Brian Zoubek only played 10.5 minutes per game scoring 3.8 points per game and 3.4 rebounds per game. He was injured for a month and his return almost directly aligned with Duke’s 11-game demise.
K has favored an offense that centers around his 2 and 3 men. It’s based on penetration and dishing instead of a strong post presence. Thus Duke took 816 of their 2084 shots, 39%, from 3-point land this season. For comparison’s sake, UNC has taken 22% of their shots from behind the arc.
Duke finished the season 6-5 in their last 11 games. If we go back to February 17 (the loss at Wake Forest), we saw Duke take 28/64, 44%, of shots from 3. The following game was a loss to Miami when the Devils took 56% of their shots from 3. Remember how they missed these shots? They were short (ie fatigue). Three games later they played at State and were lucky to win that game. They took 49% of shots from three in that game.
Fatigue
The Devils’ FG shooting percentages in their last 15 games reads like this: 41,45,44,40,41,46,46,43,39,51,33,52,43,43,38. Word is that Singler was mentally and physically exhausted in the middle of the season. Once Singler was solved by opponents (or was mentally and physically exhausted), the Duke team began shooting more shots from outside where percentages are lower and rebounds are wilder.
Clearly the weak point with this team was the conditioning and player development shortages in the interior. Once Kyle Singler hit the wall, Duke had no fall-back plan other than to shoot more 3’s. Duke has recruited big men in recent years that were highly ranked. For some reason they don’t fit in with the coaching staff. The assistant coach responsible for coaching Duke’s big men is the 5′11" former point guard Steve Wojciechowski. Perhaps it is not the recruiting of big men that is the problem. Perhaps, instead, it is the inability of Steve Wojciechowski and the coaching staff to get Freshman big men on campus to develop into a consistent players. We saw this crew try to convert Shavlik Randolph into a bulky post player with miserable results. Randolph got out while he could. Now it seems the staff is once-bitten-twice-shy about how to develop big men, and gives up on guys who don’t come in and make an immediate impact.